Sarasota County Market Reset: Signs of a Floor Emerging

Spring 2024 marked a turning point for Sarasota County’s existing single-family market. After three years of double-digit appreciation, rising insurance costs and property taxes eroded the area’s price advantage. Combined with mortgage rates averaging 6.75% (and topping 7% at times), homes stayed on the market longer and prices fell roughly 15%.
| Spring 2024 (Mar–Apr) | Summer 2025 (Jul–Aug) | Change | |
| Median Sold Price | $525,000 | $460,000 | –12.3% |
| Avg. Sold Price per Sq. Ft. | $399 | $329 | –17.5% |
Prices Have Stabilized:
May saw the cycle low at $450,000 median sold price and $323 per square foot.
Since then (June–August), prices have inched back up to $458,000 median and
$338 per square foot.
Forward-Looking Signals:
Altos Research reports the gap between median list prices and median pending
prices has narrowed across all but the top luxury tier—an indicator of
stabilizing demand.
| Tier | Median List Price | Median Pending Price |
| Top Tier | $1,696,000 | $1,325,000 |
| Upper Tier | $649,000 | $649,000 |
| Lower Tier | $435,000 | $429,450 |
| Bottom Tier | $315,000 | $299,400 |
Macro Context:
Last week’s job revisions showed 911,000 fewer U.S. jobs added April 2024–March
2025 than initially reported. With unemployment at 4.2% (approaching the Fed’s
4.5% “comfort” zone), the 10-year Treasury yield has eased to 4.04% and the
30-year conforming mortgage rate to 6.32%. The Federal Reserve is widely
expected to cut rates this week.
Outlook:
If rates trend toward or below 6% by year-end, Sarasota County should see
stronger buyer demand, firmer prices, and increased transaction volume.