Sarasota County Market Reset: Signs of a Floor Emerging


Spring 2024 marked a turning point for Sarasota County’s existing single-family market. After three years of double-digit appreciation, rising insurance costs and property taxes eroded the area’s price advantage. Combined with mortgage rates averaging 6.75% (and topping 7% at times), homes stayed on the market longer and prices fell roughly 15%.

Spring 2024 (Mar–Apr) Summer 2025 (Jul–Aug) Change
Median Sold Price $525,000 $460,000 –12.3%
Avg. Sold Price per Sq. Ft. $399 $329 –17.5%

Prices Have Stabilized:
May saw the cycle low at $450,000 median sold price and $323 per square foot. Since then (June–August), prices have inched back up to $458,000 median and $338 per square foot.

Forward-Looking Signals:
Altos Research reports the gap between median list prices and median pending prices has narrowed across all but the top luxury tier—an indicator of stabilizing demand.

Tier Median List Price Median Pending Price
Top Tier $1,696,000 $1,325,000
Upper Tier $649,000 $649,000
Lower Tier $435,000 $429,450
Bottom Tier $315,000 $299,400

Macro Context:
Last week’s job revisions showed 911,000 fewer U.S. jobs added April 2024–March 2025 than initially reported. With unemployment at 4.2% (approaching the Fed’s 4.5% “comfort” zone), the 10-year Treasury yield has eased to 4.04% and the 30-year conforming mortgage rate to 6.32%. The Federal Reserve is widely expected to cut rates this week.

Outlook:
If rates trend toward or below 6% by year-end, Sarasota County should see stronger buyer demand, firmer prices, and increased transaction volume.